On a personal note, I cannot help noting that the journal @nature could have handled this much better: for almost a full year, there was a tiny note that there is an Editorial expression of concern: https://t.co/IiFLFiIIMZ Leaving the community in the lim
Nature: Editorial Expression of Concern https://t.co/eZ5Clcekhu
The 2018 paper: https://t.co/ISxSJEO9vg The 2020 withdrawl: https://t.co/8zogrThczg
De Delftse quantum fysicus Leo Kouwenhoven zat destijds in DWDD als een bijna-zekere Nobelprijswinnaar, wegens zijn ontdekking van het Majorana-deeltje. Nu lijkt het een meetfout geweest te zijn, en er is een commissie voor ingesteld.... https://t.co/sX
No....most probably it would have been retracted, had it been accepted for review in the first place. Which in almost all cases I know of have been rejected on arrival(or soon thereafter), which only amplify the feeling of being left out in Indian academic
RT @ArindamPhysics: I never knew that Nature 'works' with the authors when data in a published paper is inadvertently (or not) mis-represen…
RT @ArindamPhysics: I never knew that Nature 'works' with the authors when data in a published paper is inadvertently (or not) mis-represen…
RT @ArindamPhysics: I never knew that Nature 'works' with the authors when data in a published paper is inadvertently (or not) mis-represen…
RT @ArindamPhysics: I never knew that Nature 'works' with the authors when data in a published paper is inadvertently (or not) mis-represen…
RT @ArindamPhysics: I never knew that Nature 'works' with the authors when data in a published paper is inadvertently (or not) mis-represen…
RT @ArindamPhysics: I never knew that Nature 'works' with the authors when data in a published paper is inadvertently (or not) mis-represen…
RT @ArindamPhysics: I never knew that Nature 'works' with the authors when data in a published paper is inadvertently (or not) mis-represen…
RT @ArindamPhysics: I never knew that Nature 'works' with the authors when data in a published paper is inadvertently (or not) mis-represen…
I never knew that Nature 'works' with the authors when data in a published paper is inadvertently (or not) mis-represented'. Would they be so forgiving had it been me? If the data is fudged the paper should be withdrawn. Period. https://t.co/6wWmiaaff9
interesting turn of events for this major work on majorana https://t.co/nNv9ja9PrL
RT @geresdi: Editorial expression of concern on the quantized Majorana study from @MSFTQuantum @QuTech_news: https://t.co/IiFLFiIIMZ "poten…
Editorial expression of concern on the quantized Majorana study from @MSFTQuantum @QuTech_news: https://t.co/IiFLFiIIMZ "potential problems in the manner in which the raw data in this Letter have been processed" @nature Scientific impact aside this is case
RT @MicrobiomDigest: Of note: An Editorial Expression of Concern posted yesterday for this 2018 @Nature paper that claimed to have measured…
RT @pjvanerp: Problemen met de Majorana studie van de groep van Leo Kouwenhoven.
RT @pjvanerp: Problemen met de Majorana studie van de groep van Leo Kouwenhoven.
Problemen met de Majorana studie van de groep van Leo Kouwenhoven.
RT @MicrobiomDigest: Of note: An Editorial Expression of Concern posted yesterday for this 2018 @Nature paper that claimed to have measured…
RT @MicrobiomDigest: Of note: An Editorial Expression of Concern posted yesterday for this 2018 @Nature paper that claimed to have measured…
Of note: An Editorial Expression of Concern posted yesterday for this 2018 @Nature paper that claimed to have measured Majorana particles. Orig. paper: https://t.co/CwLq4ET29z EoC: https://t.co/VSkgdbfuFD
Editorial Expression of Concern: Quantized Majorana conductance https://t.co/EeTFUbSAbA
Editorial Expression of Concern: Quantized Majorana conductance https://t.co/u60dC7K4ap マヨラナゼロモードの量子化伝導が見えたという2年前の論文、データ処理に問題があったかもということで著者と編集部が相談中、そういうのもあるのか
RT @emulenews: Editorial Expression of Concern: Quantized Majorana conductance https://t.co/CmutQvNRHi The authors have alerted the editors…
Editorial Expression of Concern: Quantized Majorana conductance https://t.co/CmutQvNRHi The authors have alerted the editors of Nature to potential problems in the manner in which the raw data in this Letter have been processed, and these will have an impa