The serotonin theory of depression: a systematic umbrella review of the evidence

@DiegoRuzzarin https://t.co/JL82E00D4d y no no es algo qu3 este en un foro de locos tipo 4chan, ese estudio se publico en nature y algunos miembros de la Royal Society of Psychiatry aceptaron que es valido (no todos pero cui bono).

@Eraserhead100 Laten we beginnen met het marketing verhaal van serotonine tekorten in de hersenen. Decennialang vertellen (huis)artsen dit verhaal als papegaaien na. Ze leerden het aan de universiteit. En geloofden erin. Het is geen wetenschap. https://t.c

RT @DanJohnsonAB: Reference cited. Moncrieff J, Cooper RE, Stockmann T, Amendola S, Hengartner MP, & Horowitz MA. 2022. The serotonin theor…

RT @LouisBrunel998: @Some_Writer_Cat Bah tiens par souci de déontologie parce que les zèts chialent quand on ne fourni pas ses sources sur…

@iHaqi_ فکر کنم این بود اگه اشتباه نکنم: https://t.co/LnIIjC9GjD از این بابت بحث راه افتاد که یه عده گفتن داروهای ضدافسردگی از اولشم کسشر بود و همه سرکاریم.

@DBenMoshe2 @MdBreathe @HEB https://t.co/H3igoUGTae

RT @LouisBrunel998: @Some_Writer_Cat Bah tiens par souci de déontologie parce que les zèts chialent quand on ne fourni pas ses sources sur…

@Some_Writer_Cat Bah tiens par souci de déontologie parce que les zèts chialent quand on ne fourni pas ses sources sur lesquelles on base ses dires... Voici la méta analyse qui comprend plusieurs études sur le sujet allant de 2008 à 2020: https://t.co/pHS

Reference cited. Moncrieff J, Cooper RE, Stockmann T, Amendola S, Hengartner MP, & Horowitz MA. 2022. The serotonin theory of depression: a systematic umbrella review of the evidence. Molecular Psychiatry, 1-14. @joannamoncrieff @HengartnerMP @markhoro

@calleymeans Chemical imbalance is not true, and just a profit slogan. https://t.co/LFTfOrpZ3K

@ElizabethButle1 @TRHLofficial @TuckerCarlson Brand is speaking in a comedic tone, but what he’s saying was based on a peer-reviewed research paper that was published shortly before he made that video. https://t.co/8uAHbe6SoQ

@EristheFair @HannahBerrelli @DrJessTaylor Might be referring to this👇 https://t.co/UxJEgtxDrk https://t.co/Q7da8cQU4R

@logansette @LeonardoPanetta @marcopalears Anch’io direi di andarci piano; info ufficiali false a iosa, una DR.SSA famosa venuta qui a Este: 2 verità, $cienza con S barrata e altra, quando c’entrano Ditte, Big Pharma, ecc. https://t.co/rWFIs9WW6w https://t

Der wissenschaftliche Nachweis der Serotonin Hypothese zur Begründung der Psychopharmaka ist sehr fraglich. Also: in der Behandlung der Depression mehr an die Psychotherapie denken. Die EMDR Therapie überzeugt hier durch Daten und klinische Erfahrungen. ht

RT @shannonsayshia: @Antidepressed1 https://t.co/FIpW90qv0w

@Antidepressed1 https://t.co/FIpW90qv0w

@rudolf27031961 @torfsrik https://t.co/iLGw0rSP5f

@torfsrik Nochtans zouden de voorschrijvende artsen beter dit artikel van Dr @joannamoncrieff eens doornemen: https://t.co/iLGw0rSP5f

Published in the journal Molecular Chemistry, “The serotonin theory of depression: a systematic umbrella review of the evidence” concluded that the evidence does in fact not support the serotonin theory as a cause of depression. https://t.co/S0GcEb4yWW

@oldgitfitness62 @TheBrainBattery Yes, gut health is brain health. SSRIs are neurotoxins. They don't work via the gut. They don't work - period. The low serotonin causes depression myth has been debunked by this landmark paper written by @joannamoncrieff,

@UnitedShoes @DrMcFillin https://t.co/HYa9QCdO7d

@VivienneduSud @biserometanie @gambala_codes АД - це як раз таки ніхуя не "доказова" річ. Уже рік тому навіть "доказовими" методами визначили, що це - повна хуйня і "теорія хімічного дизбалансу" теж. https://t.co/oSDMtYF3IU

https://t.co/MqwZbjn1pF https://t.co/w7kG9jAH0Q

@WallStreetSilv Recent study: "Our comprehensive review of the major strands of research on serotonin shows there is no convincing evidence that depression is associated with, or caused by, lower serotonin concentrations or activity." https://t.co/yrYoOFiw

lmao! potężna metaanaliza!!!!! sprawdźmy, ile publikacji wzięto pod uwagę!!!! ...siedemnaście. kurtyna.

zapewne nie sprawdziłeś, że owa naukowczyni i autorka badania jest znaną w świecie psychiatrii krytyczką stosowania farmakologii w przypadku leczenia chorób psychicznych i zaburzeń. to tak jakby w kwestii szczepień wypowiedział się człowiek będący ich opo

@tanisyntezator Lmao! https://t.co/2ZE42YvcjE

RT Wm & Dr @EmmyBetz 1-5 very QUICK as are both above. HEAR & READ: @JDaviesPhD CRACKED, Bob Whitaker @Mad_In_America, Dr Breggin @AmericanMD, etc. 1 https://t.co/T6PWmzDFqn 2 https://t.co/OwdoaG0bRA 3 https://t.co/PWxbMqp1fU 4 https://t.co/Z2ilpk

RT @jbjerg: @ClausEkstrom Kausalitet vs. korrelation. Forskere, der desuden stadig kegler rundt med Big Pharma-historien om serotonin-ubala…

@ClausEkstrom Kausalitet vs. korrelation. Forskere, der desuden stadig kegler rundt med Big Pharma-historien om serotonin-ubalancer som værende årsag til depression, er meget svære at tage seriøse 🙈 https://t.co/wbgnloZBCA https://t.co/rQEGzPLFh6 Scroll

https://t.co/lxZzKhgAZx

DEPRESSION: disease of the brain or a state of mind? Conversation with D... https://t.co/MvkVuvCMQh Mar 2023 The serotonin theory of depression: a systematic umbrella review of the evidence. Joanna Moncrieff et al July 2022 https://t.co/lxZzKhgAZx https

RT @pedromammini: @dougfunnyee https://t.co/2WLGFeewWx esse artigo mostra como a teoria da serotonina n descreve o fenômeno da depressão,…

Un paper muy interesante sobre el tema de la baja serotonina com oúnico causante de depresión a nivel químico: The serotonin theory of depression: a systematic umbrella review of the evidence: https://t.co/LAndvxuXcn

RT @pedromammini: @dougfunnyee https://t.co/2WLGFeewWx esse artigo mostra como a teoria da serotonina n descreve o fenômeno da depressão,…

@OGemeoMau @lftofoli Essa revisão da nature diz que não mudou muita coisa nos últimos 10 anos https://t.co/PpGddElcO4

RT @joannamoncrieff: Our new review is the first to systematic overview of all the main areas of research and concludes there is no evidenc…

RT @aquelxmeninx: https://t.co/WzHUdgssFv

https://t.co/WzHUdgssFv

quem quiser ler inclusive:

@arriettyse @smentalcritica https://t.co/PpGddElcO4

A friendly reminder that SSRIs are pretty much snake oil based on a flawed unscientific assumption. https://t.co/4BAbUB4bNG

@MyLordBebo Please note that a large umbrella study in 2021 refuted the claim that serotinin is related to mood. https://t.co/2jfUI9zJt4

@DrNathanCole @BMauschen Sorry, die These der Depression als Störung von Neurotransmittern hat ganz schwache Füße und ignoriert nicht nur komplett die klinisch-psychologische Forschung, sondern auch neuere Studien z.B. zur Serotonin-Hypothese https://t.co/

https://t.co/BqdsMnIZgt La teoría de la serotonina en la depresión: una revisión sistemática de las pruebas

RT @kyblueblood: a systematic umbrella review of the evidence” https://t.co/AYLZ4Gz1HJ #DrJoannaMoncreiff_BritishPsychiatrist #JoannaMonc…

a systematic umbrella review of the evidence” https://t.co/AYLZ4Gz1HJ #DrJoannaMoncreiff_BritishPsychiatrist #JoannaMoncrieff #JillKesti_GraphicDesign

@TheWarKitchen @oliviercantin https://t.co/sh05jDIc9O

https://t.co/aGi1BFmoBd

@hepzibah59 @Hambledown_Road https://t.co/MjM5dVNIkW

@PieAreSqwared @hepzibah59 @Hambledown_Road There are actually a lot of studies on them. They work the same as placebo plus suicides and semi temporary castration. Check this study out. Published in Nature. https://t.co/MjM5dVNIkW

@Jerdavreu https://t.co/jLOSWBP9XA

@TroncheBiais @Enthoven_R @radiofrance @Hugo_Baup @vinceflibustier @LEXPRESS ...qui ne collent pas avec son storytelling... https://t.co/ZLUYpOtm5b

@LouiseOdessa @Hugo_Baup Vous savez que le lien entre sérotonine et dépression n'est pas clair ? "The main areas of serotonin research provide no consistent evidence of there being an association between serotonin and depression" https://t.co/ayb2N1o5pl

https://t.co/H2iz1S3LF6 https://t.co/fuipErivQ6

@briebriejoy 2013🇺🇸33rd in LIFE EXPECTANCY per @johngreen. 48th now-does not list yr @CIA Factbook-2022? 🇺🇸RANK: 48th 80.75 Life-1st Med Cost-30th HC 1-5 QUICK 1 https://t.co/T6PWmzDFqn 2 https://t.co/OwdoaG0bRA 3 https://t.co/s1Hj4NWotR 4 https://t.co/PW

@Allieraine_ @FWPlayboy https://t.co/UX2mKePVjQ

@Hugo_Baup @MaxiCaveat @MaFamilleDeOuf https://t.co/qPBMNwPeaw

@soermel @larsweisbrod Wow, danke. TIL. https://t.co/V2axzhpr2D

@ZoiNetou Enthält leider veraltete Fakten? https://t.co/pCVxpQF4q6 https://t.co/A0xFqB1riI

@PSSD_sufferer The hypothesis of chemical imbalance has been debunked. https://t.co/ShJTYqKDSU

#Retweet🌎VIEW: 1 https://t.co/SynDOhabhf 2 https://t.co/nl8E9YIw0W 3 https://t.co/hGMNXnhcRG @YouTube 4 https://t.co/1xnjtAYp75 5 https://t.co/PWxbMqp1fU 6 https://t.co/Z2ilpkm7Vt 7 https://t.co/YzScyewsiG 8 https://t.co/Js8PQWPz54 9 https://t.co/RsUhy8

@Inversionism @joannamoncrieff @markhoro 2. depression myth. https://t.co/TOvqxzHnW7

RT @_daichikonno: うつ病がセロトニンの低下により引き起こされるというエビデンスはない、という驚きのsystematic review論文(2022/7)。 精神疾患を単なる神経調節物質の多寡と結びつける時代から、脳内ネットワークの異常など、より多角的にパーソ…

@faatima1216 @thairkassam No, no sugiero nada; sólo comparto la conclusión a la que llegan estudios: no hay evidencia empírica que corrobore la hipótesis de que el déficit de serotonina es la causa orgánica de la depresión. https://t.co/lHdusbajSk

For your reference you libcucks https://t.co/2kLVD9YnPZ

RT @NickdeCusa: This is too narrow a view of psychiatry, it goes beyond this, as explained with clarity by Dr Chris Palmer's Brain Energy.…

RT @sotirissays: Psychiatry is pseudoscience and psychiatrists who prescribe SSRIs are shaman charlatan scammers. Change my mind. https://…

This is too narrow a view of psychiatry, it goes beyond this, as explained with clarity by Dr Chris Palmer's Brain Energy. That book has tons of research references documenting that psychiatry goes wider than prescribing molecules. Few psychiatrists follo

Psychiatry is pseudoscience and psychiatrists who prescribe SSRIs are shaman charlatan scammers. Change my mind. https://t.co/4BAbUB4JDe

@analog_ashley The serotonin theory of depression: a systematic umbrella review of the evidence https://t.co/3wfvxBUHfv

@SourPatches2077 @DrMcFillin Recent study for Nature (top academic journal) found basically no proof that serotonin is related to depression https://t.co/6UjATCWO7d

RT @RamonNogueras: https://t.co/AzOGzrjCLd

RT @joannamoncrieff: @elonmusk @CensoredMen Thanks for highlighting overdiagnosis, Elon, but there is actually no evidence that depression…

@psk_psikolog https://t.co/K6K01WbJte Serotonin miktarı ve depresyon arasında bir alaka olduğunun kanıtı yok(muş). Bütün dünyada çook fazla kullanılan serotonin arttırıcı antidepresanlar sadece plasebo... Geçenlerde Alzheimer ilaçlarının da (amyloid plak a

@KeyPaganRush @ApexLexMusic Interesting piece on serotonin, read the last few sentences from the abstract. https://t.co/kKhvQq2pdZ

RT @NatashaSeaton2: Fascinating review about the #serotonin hypothesis of #depression. Is it foolish to be hopeful that this prompts us to…

RT-WAKE🇺🇸& #StopRealSTEAL TRILLIONS #NationalizeBANKSnFED w STOCKHOLDERS 1-3 QUICK 1 https://t.co/pQfzt6Cg5X 2 https://t.co/Jsy44aYaEh PgDn 3 https://t.co/KI7wtBg80Y 4 https://t.co/ufq1oy2RnT 5 epis1-6 https://t.co/BuzGMHyuLU 6 https://t.co/mEwLfJFVqz

RT @joannamoncrieff: @elonmusk @CensoredMen Thanks for highlighting overdiagnosis, Elon, but there is actually no evidence that depression…

https://t.co/7TmW5b6lrw.

Looking for a chance to upgrade your electronics game for free? Visit our website and claim your free $100 Best Buy gift card now. 🧧 Here : https://t.co/35p2nA4FUH

@Patrick16415378 @OfOversight @morty4texas @WriteStride @ScottAdamsSays @BestBuy A la lit: https://t.co/yLRrtTLLCy

@KartapussFR Regardez votre EBV avec les antidépresseurs : pas plus efficace qu'un placebo suivant certaines études. On peut faire dire n'importe quoi avec les études. Ce sont les patients qui parlent le mieux. https://t.co/b1YVZAoado

RT @eparquiodelgado: Llevamos más de veinte años diciéndolo: la hipótesis de un desequilibrio en la serotonina para explicar la depresión e…

https://t.co/AYLZ4Gz1HJ

RT-WAKE🇺🇸& #StopRealSTEAL TRILLIONS #NationalizeBANKSnFED w STOCKHOLDERS 1-3 QUICK 1 https://t.co/FEW3dX1bVn 2 https://t.co/7IpEp21ZeN PgDn 3 https://t.co/6TH6KD6ZeT 4 https://t.co/RqMJ3ZljqS 5 epis1-6 https://t.co/XvnjG3CCfc 6 https://t.co/2ugQKKvQBc

@BenAdamsO_O @AlecMacGillis Plenty of other sources for searching "no chemical link depression". https://t.co/fDKXxZpWae https://t.co/G2cxPQZe0N https://t.co/v8ixtmKThY You have half of USA hooked to opioids because of agressive marketing. So why won'

@elonmusk @ZubyMusic It may feel like your brain chemistry – but it’s more likely to be your social existence (yes, even yours). Serotonin deficit theory – unevidenced marketing myth. https://t.co/AEhbKagbON

@elonmusk @ZubyMusic The theory of a chemical imbalance causing depression has been completely debunked SSRIs should be taken off the market https://t.co/e4zlP3aWVN

@iciquebec Pourtant l'année passée une étude majeure à démontrer que ces pillules ne sont en grande partie que des placebo. https://t.co/YAbfxLwzQH

@CVUSMO @Kennedy__Quinn @JustJesscaa https://t.co/hrmsyZJWLO

RT #StopRealStealPHARMA 1-6 QUICK Click/PgDn 1 https://t.co/T6PWmzDFqn 2 https://t.co/OwdoaG0bRA 3 https://t.co/s1Hj4NWotR 4 https://t.co/PWxbMqp1fU 5 https://t.co/Z2ilpkm7Vt 6 https://t.co/6EkXY654x1 7 https://t.co/bG5CNlWsQI 8 https://t.co/TQanlGUu9Y 9 h

"Research provides no evidence of association between serotonin and depression & no support for the hypothesis that depression is caused by low serotonin." Of course it doesn't. It's dopamine, not serotonin. But Gov't doesn't want the public having SD

RT @timmpoe: Extremely astute commentary on the heated discussion around the recent review paper on the serotonin theory of depression

@MiguelWrites Mentira https://t.co/zeaVBMINzI

@EncesFuentes @MiguelWrites https://t.co/zeaVBMINzI

@Toasty_Takes https://t.co/4ZrnZ6fO9r

La teoría del desequilibrio químico no cuenta con evidencia firme. Por ello, análisis recientes de ensayos clínicos indican una paridad aproximada para la mayoría de los participantes entre fármaco y placebo. https://t.co/yzsixEiM4h

Eu tô 100% em negação com essa evidência científica pq confio na minha desvenlafaxina como minha mãe confia em São Longuinho pra achar as coisas perdidas https://t.co/YjJV78JrKN

RT @drtanjusurmeli: "It hasn't been proven that depression is caused by a chemical disorder. Stop telling patients that, give them treatmen…